Guidance, tools, and resources for evidence-based decisions on vaccine switches and EPI portfolio optimization

Molly Sauer

Countries now have access to an unprecedented wave of new vaccine presentation and product options and alternative schedules, with more options in the pipeline. This expanding landscape provides an opportunity for countries to examine the vaccine portfolio to identify ways to improve coverage and impact, reduce costs and wastage, and lessen the burden on the cold chain and on health workers. Each switch comes with trade-offs — it is crucial that countries assess their priorities and weigh available evidence and programmatic factors for each option.

This website provides links to guidance, resources, and tools to support countries in navigating available options and making evidence-based decisions to optimize the cost, impact, logistics or programmatic ease of their vaccine portfolio. 

Content 

  1. Vaccine portfolio optimization guidance
  2. Guidance for Gavi-eligible countries
  3. Decision-making tools and resources
  4. Vaccine-specific information

Vaccine switch type definitions and examples

 Switch type

 Definition and examples

Product

 Change to a vaccine manufactured by a different supplier and/or with a different combination or strain composition

 Examples:

 - Switch from PCV13 to PCV10 

 - Switch from PCV10-4 (Synflorix) to PCV10-5 (PNEUMOSIL)

 Presentation

 Change to a different primary presentation (vial size, blow-fill-seal), formulation (liquid, lyophilised), or delivery technology (pre-filled syringe, patches)

 Examples:

 - Switch from ROTASIIL lyophilized to ROTASIIL liquid

 - Switch from 10-dose vials for MCV to 5-dose vials

 Schedule

 Change the dose schedule of the same vaccine

 Examples:

 - Switch from 3+0 schedule for PCV to 2+1 schedule

 - Switch from 2-dose HPV vaccine schedule for the target cohort to 1-dose schedule

 Use

 Change how the same vaccine in the same formulation is administered

 Example:

 - Switch from administering IPV as an intramuscular injection to administering as a fractional dose intradermal injection

1. Vaccine portfolio optimization guidance

2. Guidance for Gavi-eligible countries

TitleAuthorYearTypeLanguage
Gavi Product MenuUNICEF2023RepositoryEnglish
Gavi Support GuidelinesGavi, the Vaccine Alliance2023GuidanceEnglish, French
Vaccine Detailed product profiles (DPPs) For Gavi-supported vaccinesGavi, the Vaccine AllianceRepositoryEnglish, French

3. Decision-making tools and resources 

Decision support tools and technical assistance 

TitleAuthorYearTypeLanguage
Country-led Assessment for Prioritization in Immunization (CAPACITI) decision-support toolWorld Health Organization (WHO)2020ToolEnglish, French, Portuguese, Spanish
Decade of Vaccine Economics (DOVE)International Vaccine Access Center (IVAC)ToolEnglish
Guidance on an adapted evidence to recommendation process for National Immunization Technical Advisory GroupsWorld Health Organization (WHO)GuidanceEnglish, Russian
Immunization Decision-Making Resource CatalogueWorld Health Organization (WHO)2023ToolEnglish
Resource Center for National Immunization Technical Advisory Groups (NITAGs) worldwideGlobal NITAG NetworkRepositorySpanish
Vaccine Economics Research for Sustainability and Equity (VERSE)International Vaccine Access Center (IVAC)ToolEnglish
 

Country experiences and lessons learned

TitleAuthorYearTypeLanguage
A Switch for Sustainability in Ghana's Rotavirus Vaccine ProgramProfessor George Armah2020Case studyEnglish
Introducing 5-dose Measles-Rubella Vaccine Vials in Zambia: Research FindingsDose Per Container Partnership2019Case studyEnglish
The effects of switching from 10 to 5-dose vials of MR vaccine on vaccination coverage and wastage: A mixed-method study in ZambiaAli Karim, Barbara Knittel, Frances Mwansa, Guissimon Phiri, Kirstin Krudwig, Natasha Kanagat, Robert Steinglass, Wendy Prosser2020Journal articleEnglish

4. Vaccine-specific information

Pneumococcal conjugate vaccines (PCV) 

TitleAuthorYearTypeLanguage
Considerations for PCV product choiceWorld Health Organization (WHO)2021GuidanceEnglish
PCV catch-up vaccination FAQCHOICES2023GuidanceEnglish, French
Pneumococcal Conjugate Vaccine Cost CalculatorPATH2020ToolEnglish
UNICEF Pricing Information-PCVUNICEF2023DatasheetEnglish
Vaccine Detailed product profiles (DPPs) For Gavi-supported vaccinesGavi, the Vaccine AllianceRepositoryEnglish, French
VIEW-hub data on PCV introductions, coverage, and productsInternational Vaccine Access Center (IVAC), Johns Hopkins UniversityToolEnglish
WHO position papersWorld Health Organization (WHO)RepositoryArabic, Chinese, English, French, Russian, Spanish

Rotavirus vaccines (RVV)

TitleAuthorYearTypeLanguage
Rotavirus Vaccine Cost CalculatorPATHToolEnglish
Summary of key characteristics of WHO Prequalified Rotavirus vaccinesWorld Health Organization (WHO)Poster/infographicEnglish
UNICEF Pricing Information-RVVUNICEF2021DatasheetEnglish
Vaccine Detailed product profiles (DPPs) For Gavi-supported vaccinesGavi, the Vaccine AllianceRepositoryEnglish, French
VIEW-hub data on RVV introductions, coverage, and productsInternational Vaccine Access Center (IVAC), Johns Hopkins UniversityToolEnglish
WHO position papersWorld Health Organization (WHO)RepositoryArabic, Chinese, English, French, Russian, Spanish

Human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccines 

TitleAuthorYearTypeLanguage
HPV Vaccine Cost CalculatorPATH2022ToolEnglish, French, Spanish
HPV VACCINE SCHEDULE OPTIMIZATION Key considerations for decision-making, planning, and implementationPATH, JSI, UNICEF, Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance, World Health Organization (WHO)2023GuidanceEnglish
UNICEF Pricing Information-HPVUNICEF2021DatasheetEnglish
Vaccine Detailed product profiles (DPPs) For Gavi-supported vaccinesGavi, the Vaccine AllianceRepositoryEnglish, French
VIEW-hub data on HPV introductions, coverage, and productsInternational Vaccine Access Center (IVAC), Johns Hopkins UniversityToolEnglish
WHO position papersWorld Health Organization (WHO)RepositoryArabic, Chinese, English, French, Russian, Spanish

Measles-containing vaccines (MCV / MR / MMR)

TitleAuthorYearTypeLanguage
MCV 5-dose Vial Assessment Support ToolLinksbridgeToolEnglish
MCV vial size switch resourcesLinksbridgeRepositoryEnglish
UNICEF Pricing Information-MCVUNICEF2021DatasheetEnglish
UNICEF Pricing Information-MMRUNICEF2021DatasheetEnglish
UNICEF Pricing Information-MRUNICEF2022DatasheetEnglish
Vaccine Detailed product profiles (DPPs) For Gavi-supported vaccinesGavi, the Vaccine AllianceRepositoryEnglish, French
VIEW-hub data on MCV introductions, coverage, and productsInternational Vaccine Access Center (IVAC), Johns Hopkins UniversityToolEnglish
VIEW-hub data on MR introductions, coverage, and productsInternational Vaccine Access Center (IVAC), Johns Hopkins UniversityToolEnglish
WHO position papersWorld Health Organization (WHO)RepositoryArabic, Chinese, English, French, Russian, Spanish

Hexavalent Vaccine

Resources not available.